Investment property

Should You Keep Your Current Home as an Investment When You Upsize?

When you buy your next home, it is tempting to keep the old one as a rental. It can work, and it can also cost you more than you expect. There is no single right answer. Here is how I compare the two options, and the questions I would work through with you first.

← Investment property guide · Read our client reviews

In short

  • Keeping the old home turns it into an investment, but the loan for your new home is private debt, so its interest is not deductible.
  • Keeping it, selling it, or a middle path (sell and use the proceeds to cut private debt) can each suit different situations.
  • Check the CGT six-year rule, the effect on your borrowing capacity and the costs of being a landlord with your accountant before you decide.
On this page
  1. What keeping your home really means
  2. Keep or sell: a side-by-side
  3. The CGT 6-year rule, in plain terms
  4. Effect on your borrowing capacity
  5. Costs and risks of being a landlord
  6. If you keep it, how I would structure the loans

General information only. Tax outcomes depend on your circumstances and the rules at the time. Confirm with a registered tax adviser before you decide.

What keeping your home really means

Keeping the old home turns it into an investment property. The loan on it, usually small, stays and its interest becomes deductible. The loan for your new home is private debt. The interest on it is not deductible, whichever property secures it, because the ATO looks at the purpose of the borrowing. See protecting investment interest deductibility. So if you use the old home’s equity to fund the new purchase, a large part of your total borrowing becomes non-deductible. That is the main trade-off.

Keep or sell: a side-by-side

  • Keeping it can suit you if you want a long-term investment in a property you already know, the rent comfortably covers the costs, your equity can fund the new purchase without stretching you, and you plan to hold for years.
  • Selling can suit you if you would rather clear or cut non-deductible debt, your borrowing capacity is tight, or you do not want to be a landlord.
  • A middle path: sell and use the proceeds to cut the private debt on the new home, then invest separately with borrowing structured for the purpose. See debt recycling.

The CGT 6-year rule, in plain terms

Your main residence is generally exempt from capital gains tax (CGT). If you move out and rent the home out, the ATO’s “absence rule” lets you keep treating it as your main residence for up to six years. If you do not rent it out, there is no six-year limit. The catch: you generally cannot treat two homes as your main residence at the same time, so claiming the old home for that period can limit the exemption on the new one. The detail matters, so read the ATO’s page on treating a former home as your main residence and confirm with your accountant before you rely on it.

Effect on your borrowing capacity

Lenders count the new home loan in full and the old home’s rent at a reduced amount, so keeping the old home often lowers what you can borrow next. See investor borrowing capacity.

Costs and risks of being a landlord

Vacancy, repairs, rates, insurance, property management fees and a possible CGT bill when you later sell the rental. Rent is not guaranteed.

If you keep it, how I would structure the loans

  • Keep each property’s loan stand-alone so you can sell or refinance either one on its own. See investment loan structure.
  • Do not put personal and investment borrowing in the same loan account.
  • Use an offset account on the private debt, not a redraw on the investment loan.
  • Review the Budget changes with your accountant. The changes are now law, and the date you acquired the property is what matters: properties held at 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 are exempt from the negative gearing changes, and the CGT changes apply to gains that accrue after 1 July 2027. See investment property tax benefits.

Want this checked for your loan?

I’ll look at your numbers before you decide. Free 20 minute strategy call, no obligation.

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

Ask me your own question →

Is it better to keep or sell my old home?

It depends on your cash flow, borrowing capacity, tax position and goals. I would model both with you.

Can I use my old home’s equity for the new home’s deposit?

Yes, but the part used for the new home is private debt, so its interest is not deductible. See using equity to buy an investment property.

Does the 6-year rule apply to me?

It can, but conditions apply. Confirm with the ATO’s guidance and your accountant.

In their words

What clients say

“I would highly recommend James Sylvester. James is very professional, friendly and was so supportive from start and finish of a very complicated property purchase and refinance. I have engaged James twice for property purchases and will continue to work with James for all future mortgage related matters. …”

Roxanne Dean · Google review

Reviews are individual experiences. Your outcome will depend on your circumstances.

Read our Google reviews →

Compare keeping and selling

I will run both options against your numbers and goals, and you can take the result to your accountant. No cost, no obligation.

James Sylvester

James SylvesterYour broker, from the first conversation to settlement

Prefer to call?

0482 086 789

General information only, not tax or financial advice. This does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Tax law can change. Obtain independent legal or tax advice where appropriate.